I suppose it's only natural that outcasts would try to critisize their
former guilds. After all, the grapes are sour if you can't reach them.

As for the so called lack of coherence between official guild doctrines
and actual guild behavior, permit me to say this:
I've read each and save for a few exceptions, all have been quite
accurate. Claiming that official guild doctrines and guild histories
mean nothing, is an uneducated statement made by someone who didn't find
what they THOUGHT should have been propper guild behavior. If there is a
severe difference between what a guild's doctrine says and what a guild
member does, it's the job of the leadership to either return that guild
member to the propper path or cast them out. Claiming it's ok to do
whatever you like in the confines of a tightly defined organization as a
guild is a call to anarchy.

And to you, Fortenrus, if you trully feel your call in life is to
protect the weak, perhaps you're doing so under the wrong banner?

Penned by my hand on the 16th of Slyphian, in the year 131 MA.